A few days ago, on Instagram, I asked you guys what I should make—homemade blueberry toaster tarts or a blueberries pie?? You guys voted and the results were exactly 50% / 50%! Ha! So, since I couldn’t decide either, I made both. But since I have already posted a recipe for blueberry pie, I’m just writing up the recipe for the toaster tarts here.
In case you’re not following along with me on Instagram (follow here!), then what you don’t know is earlier that day the kids and I picked a GIANT bucket of blueberries. We’re fortunate enough to have a cute little blueberry farm right down the road from where we live so we try to get there at least once a summer. Fresh blueberry are so key to making a good pie, so if you can find the time, I recommend picking your own, or at least buying them local so that you know they’ve been picked recently.
Okay, so the funny thing I have to admit here is, I’m not a huge fan of blueberries all that much. I don’t really like them in smoothies, they are alright by themselves but I don’t crave them like I do with blackberries, peaches, raspberries or strawberries. But put those babies in a pie, and that’s where they come to life. My favorite kind of pie, hands down, is blueberry.
So I gotta tell you though. There is a trick involved. I’m just gonna go ahead and tell you my secret… When you’re baking with blueberries, they are best when they’re tart. You want to pick them early to get them when they are perfectly tart. A little bit sweet, but a lot tart. Like a sweet-tart! That little combo is so famous because it’s a flavor profile our palettes enjoy. The sweet/sour contrast is a flavor you can get it in its most purest form, in a blueberry. How cool is that?
But there’s actually another part to my secret. Lemon. I add lemon when I bake with blueberries because even if the blueberries are tart, I like them even more tart so that sweet-tart contrast really pops in your mouth. A little lemon juice works wonders.
Since I mentioned juices, here’s another things. A blueberry pastry of any kind is typically going to come out pretty runny if you don’t add some sort of gelling agent. Which I totally thought was a term I just made up but I googled it and it’s real. Go me. I actually sound like I know what I’m talking about. Anyway, you need something that will thicken all those juices so that when you bite into your pastry, or in this case, your blueberry toaster tart, your blueberry mixture will be nice and gelled and not all runny. Learned that from experience. While blueberries have some natural pectin built in, you still need to add a bit more to really get it to firm up, especially since you’re going to be adding a little lemon juice.
Now, you could add lemon zest by just shaving off a little of a lemon rind into your blueberry mixture. The oils in the rind work to add a beautiful lemon flavor. Try that if you’re a little bit of a neat freak and you’re worried about blueberry filling oozing out the sizes of these tarts. I personally prefer the taste of lemon juice and don’t mind a little bit of ooze. Your choice. Experiment and see what you like best!
Alright, I got side tracked with the lemon talk. I want to go back and tell you about some different gelling agents I’ve tried. I’ve used tapioca pearls—instant tapioca since this doesn’t bake that long and you don’t want a grainy blueberry filling. You can also use tapioca flour which is more fine. I’ve used gelatin as well and that works quite well. For some reason I have a hard time with pectin. I haven’t been able to get that to work as well but you should be able to use that per the package and get a nice gel going on. I think the problem for me is I always want to use less sugar than what the pectin needs and it doesn’t end up gelling that well. So tapioca and gelatin are more preferred choices. Gelatin has some health benefits but it is an animal product so if you want a vegan or vegetarian option, tapioca would be a better choice for you.
Alright, finally, here are some tips about the cooking process for these tarts. First, since blueberry season falls in the summer, and I don’t like to bake in the summer if I don’t have to, I like to use the toaster oven to make these. However, you’ll have to do multiple batches. So, up to you, but you can bake these tarts in any kind of oven. You’ll want some kind of liner for your baking sheet. I use parchment paper, or if I’m using the full size oven, I use my silicon baking sheets.
That’s it! These homemade blueberry toaster tarts are super easy to make. If you’re wanting to also make a pie, get my recipe for puff pastry blueberry pie here. Enjoy!
This recipe was featured on South in Your Mouth’s Weekend Potluck.